Saturday, May 8, 2010
OHIP Decision
This article in the Globe and Mail indicates an interesting change in how OHIP may be delivered and how it's payment may be considered.
"More broadly, the case suggests Canadians should be savvier before going under the knife, asking doctors how many of a given operation they have performed, and their death and complication rates. It also raises a delicate debate: How many operations does a surgeon have to perform to be considered proficient?"
When you consider several factors, including Malcolm Gladwell's Ten Thousand Hour Theory it's hard to imagine how medical students and physicians ever see enough of a specific pathology to master it. (In case you are unfamiliar with this theory, it essentially states that to truly be the master of *something*, you need to have practiced it for 10, 000 hours. Essentially four hours a day for ten years.)
Medications and imaging reduce the severity of many pathologies we may normally see. Speaking with residents and consultants, it seems that 10 years ago putting in chest tubes and draining abdominal ascites were procedures often done.
Now though I can honestly say I've seen 2 abdominal ascites drained and 2 chest tubes placed (both on the same patient). I would not be able to perform one myself if the need arises, but now that I've finished the rotations in clerkship where I might see one, I have to hope that when residency rolls around I'll have another chance.
Something as uncommonly seen as this cavernous brain stem tumour would be difficult to master based on number of cases alone, though interesting that the American surgeon managed to amass 200 cases. Would virtual cases or those practiced on animal models count to one's mastery?
What is most concerning about the principle behind this ruling in favour of Brad's family is that if everyone decides to only be treated by the very best, those of us training to do our best are unable to learn. When the specialists retire, the patients will have set up a situation with no one to care for them.
Clearly this is taking it to the extreme, but I think the point is still valid. Medical trainees need to learn on real patients. Patients deserve the best care. These two factors do not need to be mutually exclusive and we see that in academic hospitals.
When trainees are in the OR with their consultants, the trainee does the majority of the surgery while the consultant assists. The consultant is there if the trainee needs help and to offer advice about unusual findings during the procedures. The patient gets the care of several surgeons, often two anesthesiologists and 2-3 nurses during their surgery. The trainees have read about the case and the pathology and are up on the latest findings (unless they are terrible trainees, but that's another story).
I'd feel safe in a training hospital.
But I'm still stuck on what it will take for me to be a great family doc. Our residency is only 2 years. I feel like I haven't been studying enough to be on top of everything I'm supposed to know for clerkship let alone residency. Getting my 10, 000 hours in is going to be a challenge.
Currently, I'm in the hospital on the weekend, taking an extra call shift in the hopes of seeing a new pathology I haven't seen before. I know that I learn by seeing and doing and that I can't do this from home.
"More broadly, the case suggests Canadians should be savvier before going under the knife, asking doctors how many of a given operation they have performed, and their death and complication rates. It also raises a delicate debate: How many operations does a surgeon have to perform to be considered proficient?"
When you consider several factors, including Malcolm Gladwell's Ten Thousand Hour Theory it's hard to imagine how medical students and physicians ever see enough of a specific pathology to master it. (In case you are unfamiliar with this theory, it essentially states that to truly be the master of *something*, you need to have practiced it for 10, 000 hours. Essentially four hours a day for ten years.)
Medications and imaging reduce the severity of many pathologies we may normally see. Speaking with residents and consultants, it seems that 10 years ago putting in chest tubes and draining abdominal ascites were procedures often done.
Now though I can honestly say I've seen 2 abdominal ascites drained and 2 chest tubes placed (both on the same patient). I would not be able to perform one myself if the need arises, but now that I've finished the rotations in clerkship where I might see one, I have to hope that when residency rolls around I'll have another chance.
Something as uncommonly seen as this cavernous brain stem tumour would be difficult to master based on number of cases alone, though interesting that the American surgeon managed to amass 200 cases. Would virtual cases or those practiced on animal models count to one's mastery?
What is most concerning about the principle behind this ruling in favour of Brad's family is that if everyone decides to only be treated by the very best, those of us training to do our best are unable to learn. When the specialists retire, the patients will have set up a situation with no one to care for them.
Clearly this is taking it to the extreme, but I think the point is still valid. Medical trainees need to learn on real patients. Patients deserve the best care. These two factors do not need to be mutually exclusive and we see that in academic hospitals.
When trainees are in the OR with their consultants, the trainee does the majority of the surgery while the consultant assists. The consultant is there if the trainee needs help and to offer advice about unusual findings during the procedures. The patient gets the care of several surgeons, often two anesthesiologists and 2-3 nurses during their surgery. The trainees have read about the case and the pathology and are up on the latest findings (unless they are terrible trainees, but that's another story).
I'd feel safe in a training hospital.
But I'm still stuck on what it will take for me to be a great family doc. Our residency is only 2 years. I feel like I haven't been studying enough to be on top of everything I'm supposed to know for clerkship let alone residency. Getting my 10, 000 hours in is going to be a challenge.
Currently, I'm in the hospital on the weekend, taking an extra call shift in the hopes of seeing a new pathology I haven't seen before. I know that I learn by seeing and doing and that I can't do this from home.
Friday, May 7, 2010
I stripped a varicose vein today!
That's the only exciting thing today though.
Yesterday, a pt went asystolic on the table for a minute. When we asked him about it today he responded 'oh, that happens sometimes'. As long as he's comfortable with it....
Yesterday, a pt went asystolic on the table for a minute. When we asked him about it today he responded 'oh, that happens sometimes'. As long as he's comfortable with it....
Wednesday, May 5, 2010
more iPhone/touch apps for clerkship
I started talking about the apps I had found useful in clerkship here. I still use Diagnosaurus, 5 Minute Clinical Consult and Dr. Drugs quite a bit. I also use a bunch more. I'll be the first to admit I have a ridiculous number of apps.
Wards: Patient Tracker: this is a program that lets you put the pts name, chief complaint, tests ordered and plans for discharge into your phone. It takes a bit of time to get everyone in which was a real deterrent from bothering to use it on surgery, but I did use it on medicine and found it helpful. I was walking around with lists of patient names with info scribbled under their names, updating from the previous day every day, trying not to lose a sheet and get attacked by the privacy police. (Speaking of the privacy police, there is a password requirement to enter and get the information.)
When the app first came out, you were restricted to the consults/tests in the bank. Now you can put your own in so that it becomes customized to the service.
It's great for following patients through their hospital stay and doing discharge summaries at the end since you've highlighted the big points while there were in hospital - if you take the time to enter the info. Really, time is the only drawback to this system.
P: C$4.99
Shozu: Lets you keep up with your blog between cases/in moments of serenity so your family and friends know you are alive. Easy enough to use. Doesn't let you type in landscape mode though which is a huge drawback.
P: C$4.99
Calculate (Medical Calculator) by QxMD: This really is the only calculator you'll need. And it's free. Just get it.
If you want more convincing, you can customize it to the rotation you're on or keep it at the general practitioner mode to have all calculations quickly available. It's not just fun with numbers like figuring out the anion gap, there's also check lists like the Ottawa Ankle Rules, Pediatric Glasgow Coma Scale and risk of relapse into heavy drinking.
It takes a little while to get used to all the options available to you and remembering to access them when you need them.
P: FREE!
Cardio, Heme, GI, Neph Calculators: These are all done by the MedQx guys. Just get the calculator above to have everything in one app, no redundancies.
Hospital Codebook/Phonebook: Your contacts list is a better way to handle this information. Not a useful app.
P: C$.99
A2Z of Dermatology: I'm on the fence about this app. If you already know the name of the dermatological feature you're looking for, you're away to the races. If not, it can be a bit of a long haul trying to figure out what the rash is that you're looking at. I'd prefer to see this as an algorhythm type app - like a derm calculator "what colour is the lesion" "is it elevated"...you have melanoma! Ah, maybe that's why, too much like diagnosing your own illness. But I digress.
The app lists the lesions in alphabetical order by their commonly known name. It gives you a photo and a description of what the lesion is, what may have caused it and often a treatment. There is usually a link through to Google images for other examples of the lesion, which is helpful.
But, not really worth the dough. Use google yourself for this.
P: C$3.99
more soon...
Wards: Patient Tracker: this is a program that lets you put the pts name, chief complaint, tests ordered and plans for discharge into your phone. It takes a bit of time to get everyone in which was a real deterrent from bothering to use it on surgery, but I did use it on medicine and found it helpful. I was walking around with lists of patient names with info scribbled under their names, updating from the previous day every day, trying not to lose a sheet and get attacked by the privacy police. (Speaking of the privacy police, there is a password requirement to enter and get the information.)
When the app first came out, you were restricted to the consults/tests in the bank. Now you can put your own in so that it becomes customized to the service.
It's great for following patients through their hospital stay and doing discharge summaries at the end since you've highlighted the big points while there were in hospital - if you take the time to enter the info. Really, time is the only drawback to this system.
P: C$4.99
Shozu: Lets you keep up with your blog between cases/in moments of serenity so your family and friends know you are alive. Easy enough to use. Doesn't let you type in landscape mode though which is a huge drawback.
P: C$4.99
Calculate (Medical Calculator) by QxMD: This really is the only calculator you'll need. And it's free. Just get it.
If you want more convincing, you can customize it to the rotation you're on or keep it at the general practitioner mode to have all calculations quickly available. It's not just fun with numbers like figuring out the anion gap, there's also check lists like the Ottawa Ankle Rules, Pediatric Glasgow Coma Scale and risk of relapse into heavy drinking.
It takes a little while to get used to all the options available to you and remembering to access them when you need them.
P: FREE!
Cardio, Heme, GI, Neph Calculators: These are all done by the MedQx guys. Just get the calculator above to have everything in one app, no redundancies.
Hospital Codebook/Phonebook: Your contacts list is a better way to handle this information. Not a useful app.
P: C$.99
A2Z of Dermatology: I'm on the fence about this app. If you already know the name of the dermatological feature you're looking for, you're away to the races. If not, it can be a bit of a long haul trying to figure out what the rash is that you're looking at. I'd prefer to see this as an algorhythm type app - like a derm calculator "what colour is the lesion" "is it elevated"...you have melanoma! Ah, maybe that's why, too much like diagnosing your own illness. But I digress.
The app lists the lesions in alphabetical order by their commonly known name. It gives you a photo and a description of what the lesion is, what may have caused it and often a treatment. There is usually a link through to Google images for other examples of the lesion, which is helpful.
But, not really worth the dough. Use google yourself for this.
P: C$3.99
more soon...
Monday, May 3, 2010
recharging my battery
Despite being incredibly sick during this conference I feel so excited. Being around this many people who want to improve medical education has opened my eyes to options in my future career. I've met and networked with some wonderful people. I'm now aware that a masters of medical education. I'd planned on doing a M. Ed but now that I know this exists I'm wacky excited.
I've also been made aware of several potential research projects that I'd be excited to initiate.
I also made it to a talk on how to write a better paper for admission to a medical journal.
bliss
Friday, April 30, 2010
good clerks should be seen and not heard
It took me a while to figure out, but it's now clear to me that one of the reasons that I haven't gotten along well with my residents is that they prefer yes men.
Any independent thought or questions are discouraged.
Any independent thought or questions are discouraged.
Thursday, April 29, 2010
it's always safe to blame the med student
In a 30 hour call shift I managed to get stern words from a circulating nurse who was watching me like a hawk and waiting for me to contaminate myself, a resident from another service who didn't like how I was presenting someone else's case and my own resident who thought I should have woken her up this morning. Presumably with a mint on the pillow.
Of these 3, guess which one actually apologised for being an ass?
The one who actually had a point.
I didn't do a very good job of presenting the case for referral to the resident, I didn't really know the patient. But he still came down to the ED to apologise for being an ass.
The other 2, actually in the wrong, are just jerks I guess.
Of these 3, guess which one actually apologised for being an ass?
The one who actually had a point.
I didn't do a very good job of presenting the case for referral to the resident, I didn't really know the patient. But he still came down to the ED to apologise for being an ass.
The other 2, actually in the wrong, are just jerks I guess.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
